How to Check New Headphones: 5 Simple Steps to Decide Whether to Keep or Return Them

Buying a new pair of headphones usually comes with a bit of excitement. You try a few familiar songs, everything seems “okay,” and you move on. If something feels slightly off, it’s easy to assume you just need time to adjust.

The problem is that headphones are surprisingly easy to adapt to. Minor channel imbalance, subtle distortion, or discomfort when worn longer often don’t stand out in the first few minutes. Weeks later—when the return window is gone—you may finally realize the issue was never “getting used to them.”

This article walks you through five simple but important checks you should do right after buying new headphones. They help you evaluate sound, connectivity, and comfort early, so you can decide whether to keep them, exchange them, or look for a better fit for your needs.

Why the First Days With New Headphones Matter

Most retailers offer a return or exchange window of around 7–14 days. This short period is your only chance to assess a pair of headphones objectively, before your ears and brain start compensating for small flaws.

Headphones are deeply personal devices. Small issues may feel tolerable at first but become frustrating with daily use. Checking early isn’t about nitpicking—it’s about avoiding the mistake of accepting a flawed experience simply because you’ve adapted to it.

5 Simple Checks to Spot Headphone Issues Early

1. Check if the Left and Right Channels Are Balanced

One of the most serious yet commonly overlooked problems is channel imbalance. At first, the difference may feel subtle. Over time, it becomes harder to ignore as the soundstage feels skewed or “off-center.”

From a technical standpoint, this usually points to a driver or internal circuit issue and rarely improves with use. That’s why studio-oriented headphones, known for precise channel matching, are often used as references. With models like the Sony MDR-7506, even a slight imbalance is immediately noticeable.

If a mono track or a centered vocal consistently pulls to one side, it’s a sign worth taking seriously.

👉 More detail about Sony MDR-7506

2. Check for Distortion at Higher Volumes

Listening at high volumes isn’t recommended, but well-made headphones should still maintain clarity when pushed slightly above normal listening levels.

If your new headphones start sounding harsh, fuzzy, or distorted early on, the driver may be struggling. This isn’t about bass tuning or sound signature—it’s about how well the hardware controls distortion. Well-tuned hi-fi headphones such as the Sennheiser HD 560S tend to remain clean and composed at higher volumes, making distortion easier to identify.

If you lower the volume simply because the sound becomes uncomfortable, that’s a warning sign.

👉 More detail about Sennheiser HD 560S

3. Check Connection Stability in Real-World Use

With wireless headphones, connection quality is just as important as sound. Put your phone in your pocket, walk around your home, turn your head, or bend down. Notice whether the signal cuts out or stutters.

Many people only discover connection problems after several days of real-world use, especially outdoors. In the true wireless category, the difference between casual-use earbuds and reliable daily drivers shows clearly here. Models praised for stability, like the Jabra Evolve2 True Wireless, typically hold a solid connection during light movement.

Frequent dropouts in normal conditions usually point to a design or hardware limitation, not your environment.

👉 More detail about Jabra Evolve2 True Wireless

4. Check Noise Cancellation in Everyday Settings

Active noise cancellation doesn’t mean total silence. A good system reduces background noise consistently without creating pressure or discomfort.

Test ANC in familiar environments—near a fan, traffic noise, or a café. If noise cancellation feels inconsistent or becomes uncomfortable after a few minutes, that’s worth noting. Well-balanced ANC headphones, such as the Sony WH-1000XM5, aim to reduce noise while keeping the listening experience natural and comfortable.

Discomfort caused by ANC rarely disappears over time. It often becomes more noticeable with longer sessions.

👉 More detail about Sony WH-1000XM5

5. Check Comfort After 30–60 Minutes of Use

A pair of headphones can feel fine for the first five minutes and become problematic after half an hour. Pressure, clamping force, and heat buildup only show up with extended use.

Headphones designed for long sessions tend to remain comfortable over time rather than gradually causing fatigue. If discomfort appears within 30–60 minutes, it’s not something you should ignore. This also explains why some users prefer comfort-first designs, such as open-ear models like the SHOKZ New OpenFit 2+, which prioritize wearability over isolation.

Comfort issues rarely improve with time.

👉 More detail about SHOKZ New OpenFit 2+

Technical Issues vs. Design Differences

Not every dissatisfaction is a defect. Light bass, forward mids, or a narrower soundstage may simply reflect the manufacturer’s tuning choices. In contrast, channel imbalance, distortion, and unstable connections are almost always technical problems.

Knowing the difference helps you avoid returning headphones just because they don’t match your preferences—and prevents you from accepting flaws that shouldn’t be there in the first place.

Different Headphone Types Need Different Standards

True wireless headphones should be judged heavily on connection stability and portability. Over-ear models deserve closer attention to weight, clamping force, and noise cancellation. With on-ear designs, weaker isolation is often an expected trade-off.

Applying the same standards across all types can lead to poor evaluations and disappointing choices.

A 5-Minute Checklist for New Headphones

• Play a mono track to check left–right balance

• Increase volume briefly to check for distortion

• Walk around to test wireless stability

• Try noise cancellation in familiar environments

• Wear them continuously for at least 30 minutes

A few minutes of testing can save you weeks of frustration later.

Keep Them, Exchange Them, or Switch Types?

If you notice clear technical issues, returning or exchanging early is the right call. If the problem is comfort or isolation, the design may simply not suit your needs. In many cases, switching to a different headphone type leads to a better experience—even without spending more.

Good headphones aren’t something you slowly learn to tolerate. They should feel right from the start.

👉 YOU MAY LIKE:

• Nothing Ear: What Real-World Upgrades Should Users Expect?